Ah, well…the battle lines are still being drawn, so nothing wrong with a little discussion–even if I’m NOT a member of RWA (originally intended to stand for Romance Writers of America).
The ‘battle’, for those who don’t haunt the websites of ‘romance’ writers, has to do with this high-powered organization suddenly coming up with new ‘guidelines’ that seem to restrict a large portion of their own membership.
I won’t even get into the graphics argument (at the moment). Suffice to say that the lovely painting that graces the cover of my book (see Incubus) would probably not be allowed.
The new definition of ‘romance’ is also interesting. A ‘love-focused story’ is not technically to be considered a romance. It must also have an ‘emotionally satisfying ending’.
Hello?
Doesn’t that leave out trivial little stories like Romeo and Juliet? How about Wuthering Heights? The romance between Rhett and Scarlett? And for those who enjoyed the movie ‘Titanic’–uh-uh, that’s out too, folks. A bittersweet story cannot be considered a romance.
Apparently, many paranormals are also out (romance must be between two PEOPLE), menages, etc. OUT..
Not to mention the use of certain words, most of them with four letters, that’ll earn you a nasty slap on the wrist and possible de-linking from the sacred site (gasp!). Even the new erotica group, ’sanctioned’ by the RWA, was forbidden to use the word ‘erotica’ in their NAME.
According to the RWA, this is not meant to censor anyone in any way.
Well, I’m sorry, but if it looks like dung, smells like manure, and you’re spreading it on the lawn, it’s shit.
I am a Black person. I’ve known discrimination. I am a woman. I’ve known discrimination. I am a tad overweight (love relative words like ‘tad’). I’ve known discrimination. I know it when I see it, smell it, get slapped in the face by it.
It’s usually the by-product of fear and ignorance, and it’s an ugly thing, and pretty easy to recognize. Doesn’t matter how you color or justify it.
Pssst! RWA? Your job is to provide services for your members. The members who PAY you. You have no business being the ‘morality police’.
And if you want to commit suicide by alienating the writers and readers of erotica, the fastest-growing ‘romance’ sub-genre out there, I’d say you were writing your own tragic ending.